Once Upon a Time has done it again. Making us examine everything in fine detail and making us come up with exciting theories.

When I posted the pictures of Captain Hook (Colin O’Donoghue) and William Smee (Chris Gauthier) on one of the rooftops in Storybrooke the other day, I hadn’t noticed what Smee was holding. Quite a few of you guys did however and have left comments on that post.

Is William Smee holding Baelfire’s cloak?

It seems to look like it, doesn’t it. This opens up a whole host of questions regarding episode 11 of the hit TV Show.

How did Smee get hold of the cloak?
Is Baelfire in Storybrooke and is Captain Hook looking at him through his spyglass?
Is Baelfire Peter Pan?
Is Baelfire Henry’s father, Neal Cassady?
Does Mr. Gold know that Hook and Smee have his cape (if it even is his cape)?

Robert Carlyle mentioned to me a few months back that his character and Hook were in for quite a battle, but is this what he meant? We know already that Rumpelstiltskin’s wife, Milah left him for Hook and that they’ve already battled it out once. But, if Hook knows the whereabouts of Baelfire who knows what could happen.

Actually, does Rumpelstiltskin even know that Hook is in Storybrooke?

I really appreciate how the show’s writers have written such an amazing story for us to follow every week and how they make us think so much. It does get confusing at times though, but I like that, because you know the confusion you’re experiencing now will make sense somewhere down the line.

What do you guys think? I would really like to hear your views and theories on this. Let me know in the comments below.

Image ©2012 PUNKD_Images – Used with permission