Once Upon a Time – Who will die?

Posted by

A major, series regular will die in the upcoming second half of the third season, but who will it be.

The Once Upon a Time fandom is already at breaking point following the news yesterday that one of their beloved characters will be leaving the show for good. Dead means dead in this case.

Who do you think will go?

58 Responses

  1. lans says:

    pls let it be hook can’t stand this pervert

  2. anonymousse says:

    Please let it be Neal. Can’t stand that homeless-looking dude!

    • Tanya says:

      What’s wrong with you people above? You make me worry about the human race. They are both fine actors and decent men. Go and take a long hard look at yourselves before you make such vile comments about others.

  3. As you wish says:

    I want none of them to die, even if I have favorites characters and some I like less. The hiatus was fun when we only thought about Emma’s memories, where Rumple is and how he will come back, what will happen with the Wicked Witch, who will get married, who can be Christopher Gorham’s character, and for shippers (especially CS), what would happen with the characters involved. The death spoiler ruins everything we could speculate for and now it’s just boring and scary. I would have prefered not knowing a major character is going to die until the times comes…

  4. Tiffany says:

    Please not my Killian. =(

  5. oncey says:

    I have a feeling the actress that plays Snow will go on permanent maternity leave and that’s why Snow will get killed off. Really don’t like the idea of Snowing being broken up.

  6. KoohkcuF says:

    Captain Vulgarity out!

  7. Sol says:

    Neal. Serves no purpose just a plot device.

    And grow up and stop calling names when really when Hook isnt one or any other names ppl like to throw at him

  8. Gill says:

    Neal – who does nothing really!

    He’s just a name – son, father and ex lover – who effect them in emotions and moves their story ahead thats it.

  9. Julia says:

    It’s got to be either Neal or Hook because of the love triangle thing … whenever there’s a love triangle one of the guys usually gets killed off.

  10. noshipper says:

    please let it be regina/hook/neal i can’t stand the SwanQueen/CaptainSwan/SwanThief !!!

  11. Jean says:

    It should be Hook. He is so annoying this season and has no longer any purpose on the show besides chasing Emma like a lovesick puppy. So pathetic and disappointing. Give him some hero’s death and let his redemption arc end.

  12. Sarah says:

    I don’t want anyone to but i know one of them is. I just don’t want it to be anyone in the charming family or regina. i love belle,neal, and hook but i’d be less depressed over it being one of them than being the charming family or regina.

  13. ella says:

    Let ut be Neal pleasee abd not Hook

    • hanna says:

      AGREED! :) If it;s Hook then I’ll be spending the rest of my life crying in a corner. He’s brought so much to the show that I can’t imagine it without him now!

  14. anonymoose says:

    Please let the mumbling hobo go far, far away. Bye bye neal.

  15. klara says:

    I think it’s Charming…but hopefully this will be the Hook.

  16. haaay says:

    i seriously can’t wait but all i know is that i’m going to cry.

    also you both (@lans&@anonymousse) should learn to have some respect, leave your nasty comments for yourselves. it would be better for everyone. :)

  17. Irene says:

    It’s Hook. “Believe a pirate can be a hero” he’s gonna sacrifice himself and become the hero the writers are promoting him to be.

  18. Tanya says:

    What’s wrong with you people above? You make me worry about the human race. They are both fine actors and decent men. Go and take a long hard look at yourselves before you make such vile comments about others.

  19. Ronnie says:

    Please let it be neither one. ^

  20. Jessie says:

    Please don’t let it be Hook!!!!!. He’s the hottest guy and best character. There’s no one better for Emma. I hope it’s Belle…..can’t stand her and Rumple together. Yuck!!!

    • hanna says:

      I’m with you on the Hook thing! He’s brought so much to the show I can’t bare the thought of his certain death, he’s perfect for Emma! We can only hope (X)

  21. ann says:

    i’m a CSer and i don’t want Hook die of course, and as much as i hate hate hate hate Neal i don’t want him die, i don’t want anyone die tbh :(

  22. Anonymous says:

    It cannot be more obvious that Hook is the one who dies. Colin O. just seems disconnected.

    • hanna says:

      Considering he just moved himself and his family up to Vancouver to dedicate his time more easily to the show? It would be pretty pointless if he knew he was going to die…

  23. Desa's Mom says:

    I think the best thing would be if Once Upon A Time got cancelled. I think Adam Horowitz and Eddy Kitsis have hurt and disappointed enough people with their “story”.

    • mic77 says:

      totally agree…the whole show has become a mess…doesn’t even resemble season 1…continuity issues and plot holes galore.

  24. Binali says:

    Hook please be Hook

  25. lauhall says:

    Hopefully it will be Neal, I have nothing against him, but he is sooooo boring

    • hanna says:

      Agreed. In my opinion, Hook brings so much to the show but Neal is just boring and never has any dramatic storylines and his whole character is too mellow and chilled for the drama of the rest of the show :’)

  26. Riley says:

    Regina or Hook, hate both, byes.

    • mhgkg says:

      Shut up! How can you hate Regina? She’s been sacrificing everything for everyone and without her the Charmings won’t stand a chance against any villain or any trouble. Hook is good too… How can you hate them? Both of their stories are heartbreaking and still they survive and try to be good! Place yourself in her shoes and let’s see it you’d do better!

  27. Romane says:

    Please let it be the people who last comment, can’t stand haters.

  28. Romane says:

    Judging on looks or a few innuendos, how poor of you

  29. DJ says:

    I checked IMDB.com and Michael Raymond-James is the only one of the regular cast who does not have any episodes after New York Serenade listed.

    • Lia says:

      Wow…ok…Thanks!! That clears things up! I mean, I don’t WANT anyone to die, but I kind of figured it would be Neal. MRJ has gotten a lot of hate, and I don’t know if I would stick around either, all things considered…

    • Vickie says:

      He shows up in episode 15 & 16 on the cast list.

  30. Princess says:

    The death is Hook. It’s obvious in so many ways. I was excited about the rest of the season, but now there’s a black cloud hanging over it. My parade got rained on. I just wish the producers would go ahead and release that information to the fans, so others can look forward to the rest of the season without having to be afraid their favorite may be about to die. That just ruins it all for everybody.

  31. Jo says:

    Theory: It’s Hook, and ***gasp*** Henry is the one who kills him…..and we don’t know why until season 4.

  32. mypost says:

    I LOVE Neal and will be so sad if it’s him. I don’t want anyone to die, but if I have to choose, it would be Belle. Or Hook.

  33. Laurie says:

    I really like Neal – I think because of the fact that he is so unique as an actor and the way that he plays the role. So I hope it’s not him. But I really don’t want it to be anyone – I am kind of in denial but I know it’s going to happen. So it’s a bad thing, in my opinion. But I accept it and just hope it makes sense from a story perspective. My vote is “make it go away!”

  34. anne says:

    It’s not Hook. It was confirmed that the death scene has already been shot and occurs before episode 3×16, which is being filmed now. Hook was seen filming for 3×16 with Henry.

  35. Leny1 says:

    I hope its Neal… he doesnt seem to do anything then just a plot device! He doesnt react or do anything… to be he is the only one i would want out of the cast to be hoenst, his character isnt memorable or nothing

    And Hook/Emma are the build up here with romance so i dont see that happening, dont make sense when they have built them up so well, and how they fit each other

  36. Emma says:

    This unfair this show is ruining my lifd. I really dont want anyone to die, esp Neal , Belle, and Emma (my babies) anyone else I din’t care that much. The charmings bore me so I wouldnt be upset if one of them died. Hook has no intrest to me. But Just hope no one dies for the sake if the prducers cuz no matter who dies people will be mad and go after them.

  37. R says:

    Lol @ anyone other than Hook, Neal, and Belle even being mentioned on the list. Please.

  38. Colin says:

    I don’t think it would be Neal since he already had a presumed death from 2.21 to 3.05, during which everybody mourned him a lot. I don’t think they would repeat this storyline.

    Hook is even more possible since him dying in the rest of Season 3 would immediatly allow Colin to become a series regular on the Neverland spin-off next year (there is indeed a Neverland spin-off rumoured, Robbie Kay being very exited about it, though it doesn’t mean it will be approved by ABC). I don’t see how Hook could be a recurring character on that show if he was still a regular on Once Upon a Time (and Captain Hook is essential in the Peter Pan mythology).

    Finally, major characters often died during centric episodes (Cora and Graham), and 3.17 is titled “Jolly Roger”.

  39. CS says:

    Guys, what’s wrong with you? You may ship CS or ST but that doesn’t make you an enemy of hook or neal! They both have important in ouat and you say “die hook!” “No you die neal!!” Isn’t that so absurd?? Please calm down and act like a human, alright?

  40. Emily says:

    I absolutely LOVE Neal and I would be hysterical if he died. Hook, on the other hand? Not so much…

    • Sarah says:

      I totally agree! I do not see in any way possible how Hook is attractive or Emma’s “True Love”. He also has no connections to anyone on the show besides Emma, so … ?

  41. Michelle says:

    I’m guessing it will be Ruby (Little Red Riding Hood), as she hasn’t really been in the episodes this year, and I must admit I almost fell off my bed (I watch the show stretched out in my bedroom), when I saw her in the last couple of episodes. It’s not because I don’t love Meghan Ory, I do. It’s due to the fact that she’s now doing another show – Intelligence that she is a main character on the show, instead of a supporting actress. So sad to see Ruby leaving the show.

    This is just my guess, due to this new show of her Meghan’s.

  42. Neal ... says:

    As you can probably tell by my name, I hope it is NOT Neal that dies. If he dies, I seriously will curl up into a ball, find someplace to hibernate and never wake up until I die (OK that was kind of an exaggeration, but whatever).

  43. Miko says:

    It doesnt matter who dies. This season is probably the last. In any event, It’s probably one of four characters: Hook, Neal ,Red, or the fairy. The latter is more likely since she’s in or been appearing in another tv show, the same as the fairy.

Leave a Reply to hanna